Research news
The retracted ACV weight loss study: what it means for Slim Melt
The apple cider vinegar weight loss study from March 2024 was retracted by BMJ on September 25, 2025, after statisticians could not reproduce its results (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction)) (Retraction Watch, 2025) . The trial reported young people losing 6 to 8 kg in 12 weeks on daily vinegar. What remains is a handful of small trials on liquid vinegar, not gummies.
Written by the Slim Melt editorial teamUpdated · 7 min read

The claim
What did the 2024 apple cider vinegar trial claim?
It claimed big results. The trial, published in March 2024 in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention and Health, reported that overweight teens and young adults in Lebanon lost an average of 6 to 8 kg in 12 weeks on daily apple cider vinegar (Retraction Watch, 2025).
That was far more than earlier vinegar studies found, and ads repeated it widely. If an ACV gummy ad mentions a study with dramatic loss, it may well be this one.
The retraction
Why did BMJ retract the apple cider vinegar study?
Because the results could not be reproduced. On September 25, 2025, about 18 months after publication, BMJ Group retracted the paper after independent statisticians could not reproduce the analysis (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction)).
- Analytical errors. The published numbers did not follow from the data supplied.
- Data irregularities. Patterns in the data did not fit random assignment to groups (Retraction Watch, 2025).
- No prospective registration. The trial was not registered before it began, so its plan could not be checked (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction)).
The authors called the errors honest mistakes but agreed to the retraction (Retraction Watch, 2025). BMJ asked others to stop citing the results (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction)).
It is not always a finding of fraud. It means the numbers should not guide decisions, including buying decisions.
The evidence left
What does the remaining evidence on ACV and weight loss show?
Small effects from liquid vinegar in short trials, and nothing on gummies.
| Source | What it tested or found | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Kondo 2009 (Kondo et al., 2009) (Jeukendrup, 2023 (mySportScience)) | 15 or 30 mL liquid vinegar daily for 12 weeks; about 1-2 kg more loss than placebo, regained within 4 weeks of stopping | Stands; small effect |
| Khezri 2018 (Khezri et al., 2018) | 30 mL daily plus a 250 kcal daily calorie cut beat diet alone in 39 adults over 12 weeks | Stands; small study |
| Lebanese trial 2024 (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction)) | Claimed 6 to 8 kg in 12 weeks | Retracted; do not use |
| Castagna 2025 meta-analysis (Castagna et al., 2025 (meta-analysis)) | Modest effect, significant only at 30 mL a day, across 10 short trials | Included the retracted trial; read with caution |
| Launholt 2020 review (Launholt et al., 2020 (systematic review)) | Only 13 human studies, of inadequate quality | Stands |
| Hadi 2021 meta-analysis (Hadi et al., 2021 (meta-analysis)) | Small, inconsistent blood sugar and cholesterol changes across 9 trials | Stands; not about weight |
Pooled reviews can carry a bad study forward, as the 2025 meta-analysis did. Mayo Clinic says apple cider vinegar is not likely to cause weight loss (Mayo Clinic, ACV for weight loss). RxList rates the weight evidence as insufficient (RxList, Apple cider vinegar), and Memorial Sloan Kettering calls it not conclusive (MSK Cancer Center, Apple cider vinegar).
Eating fewer calories plus more activity
StrongThe approach behind lasting weight loss; CDC advises 1-2 pounds a week. (CDC, Steps for losing weight) (Mayo Clinic, Weight-loss supplements)
Losing 5% of body weight
StrongEven 10 pounds for a 200-pound person can improve blood pressure, cholesterol and blood sugar. (CDC, Steps for losing weight)
Liquid ACV, 30 mL a day, with a diet
Small39 adults on a calorie-cut diet lost more with ACV than diet alone over 12 weeks. (Khezri et al., 2018)
Liquid ACV, 15-30 mL a day, alone
SmallAbout 1-2 kg more than placebo in 12 weeks, regained within 4 weeks of stopping. (Kondo et al., 2009) (Jeukendrup, 2023 (mySportScience))
ACV pooled studies
MixedA 2025 meta-analysis saw a modest effect at 30 mL a day only, and it included a trial later retracted. (Castagna et al., 2025 (meta-analysis)) (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction))
ACV gummies
No trialsNo published trial has tested vinegar gummies for weight. (MSK Cancer Center, Apple cider vinegar) (NIH ODS, Weight-loss supplements (HP))
B vitamins for weight loss
No evidenceB vitamins help only if you are low; none is listed as a weight-loss ingredient. (NIH ODS, Weight-loss supplements (HP)) (Mayo Clinic, B12 and weight loss)
Bar length shows how much published evidence supports each option for osteoarthritis pain and function, based on the guideline and reviews linked here. A reading aid, not a score from any one source.
For gummy buyers
What does the retraction mean for Slim Melt and other ACV gummies?
The strongest-sounding study is gone, and none of those left tested gummies. Every trial above used liquid vinegar, mostly 15 to 30 mL a day, or 750 to 1,500 mg of acetic acid (Kondo et al., 2009).
A Slim Melt serving lists 1,000 mg of unfiltered apple cider vinegar with at least 5% total acids. By our own arithmetic, that is about 50 mg of acids, roughly one fifteenth of the lower trial dose. The label says total acids, not acetic acid, so this is approximate. Our gummies vs liquid vinegar post walks through the math.
We sell Slim Melt, and you should still know this. Treat it as a low-sugar daily habit with three B vitamins, not as proven to cause loss.

Try Slim Melt for 30 days2 gummies a day · 60 per bottle · today's price at checkout
See today's priceReader skills
How can I spot a shaky study in a supplement ad?
Ask a few plain questions. The FTC says health claims need human trials on the same dose and form sold (FTC, Health Products Compliance Guidance).
Is it still standing?
Search the study title with the word retracted (Retraction Watch, 2025).
Same form, same dose?
A liquid vinegar study says little about a gummy with a fraction of the acid.
Was it registered?
Missing registration was one of the problems here (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction)).
Is the result too big?
If one study finds several times the effect of all others, wait for a repeat.
Does it promise loss without effort?
The FTC lists loss without diet or exercise as a red flag (FTC, Gut Check guide).
More warning signs are in our post on weight-loss supplement red flags.
What still works
If ACV is not the answer, what helps with weight?
The unglamorous basics. Mayo Clinic notes little proof that any supplement helps long-term weight loss (Mayo Clinic, Weight-loss supplements).
CDC recommends 1 to 2 pounds a week. Losing 5% of body weight, about 10 pounds for a 200-pound person, can improve blood pressure, cholesterol and blood sugar (CDC, Steps for losing weight). That comes from eating a little less and moving a little more, for months.
Our guide on how to lose weight safely has a plain starter plan.
Bottom line
So does apple cider vinegar help with weight loss at all?
Maybe slightly, at liquid doses, alongside a diet, and the effect fades when you stop (Jeukendrup, 2023 (mySportScience)) (Khezri et al., 2018). The trial that suggested much more was retracted. No study has tested ACV gummies or Slim Melt. If a product page cites the March 2024 trial, its results should no longer be used.
FAQ
Questions about the retracted ACV study
Was the apple cider vinegar weight loss study retracted?
Yes. BMJ Group retracted the March 2024 Lebanese trial on September 25, 2025, after statisticians could not reproduce its results and found data irregularities (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction)). The trial had claimed 6 to 8 kg average loss in 12 weeks.
Is the ACV weight-loss study fake?
The journal did not call it fraud. It found analytical errors, data patterns inconsistent with random assignment, and no advance trial registration (BMJ Group, 2025 (retraction)) (Retraction Watch, 2025). Either way, the results should not be relied on.
Do any good studies support apple cider vinegar for weight loss?
A few small ones. A 2009 Japanese trial found about 1-2 kg more loss than placebo over 12 weeks with liquid vinegar, regained after stopping (Jeukendrup, 2023 (mySportScience)). A 2018 trial found a small added benefit with a calorie cut (Khezri et al., 2018). None tested gummies.
Does the retraction change the 2025 ACV meta-analysis?
It should make you more cautious about it. The 2025 meta-analysis pooled 10 short trials, found a modest effect only at 30 mL a day, and included the retracted trial (Castagna et al., 2025 (meta-analysis)). Its pooled numbers may overstate the effect.
Do ACV gummies have any weight loss research?
No published trial has tested ACV gummies, including Slim Melt. The research uses liquid vinegar at much higher acid doses (Kondo et al., 2009). Memorial Sloan Kettering calls the weight evidence not conclusive (MSK Cancer Center, Apple cider vinegar).
How do I check if a study has been retracted?
Search the study title plus the word retracted, and check the journal page for a notice. If an ad cites a study without a title, journal or year, treat its claim with doubt (Retraction Watch, 2025).
Why was the apple cider vinegar study cited for Slim Melt retracted?
BMJ retracted it on September 25, 2025 after statisticians could not reproduce the results and found data irregularities in the 12 week trial. It is no longer valid evidence.
Does the retraction affect Slim Melt gummies?
It removes the largest claim of weight loss from vinegar. Slim Melt itself was never tested, and the remaining small trials used liquid vinegar, not gummies, with modest effects.
What does the retraction mean for how I take Slim Melt?
Slim Melt is taken as the label directs, 2 gummies once a day. The retraction concerns one published trial, so use your own simple log to follow your routine.
Who wrote this
Written and reviewed by
Plain-language pages built from the bottle label and linked medical sources.
Last updated . See our editorial standards and how we check reviews. This website is run by an authorized U.S. retailer, not by the manufacturer. Buying through our order links earns us a commission.
Keep reading
More about Slim Melt

ACV weight-loss research
Kondo, Khezri, the meta-analyses and the retracted trial, read side by side with their real effect sizes.
Read more
Apple cider vinegar
Liquid vinegar trials, the 2025 retraction, the gummy's dose math, and the safety points that matter.
Read more
Results timeline
What a realistic month looks like, what trials found, and a weekly log you can copy.
Read moreUSA authorized Slim Melt retailer
Ready to try Slim Melt?
Pick a pack. Two gummies a day, 30 days a bottle. Check today's price and the return terms on the order page before you pay.
- Secure checkout
- Return terms shown before you pay
- Tracking in the order email
